ABOUT THIS BLOG

John Tamanaha

MSNBC.com contributor John Tamanaha tackles the hot topics in college football. From title contenders and Heisman hopefuls to coaches on the hot seat and recruiting battles, no issue is out of bounds.



Heisman race? Glad you asked

Posted: Tuesday, October 09, 2007 8:47 PM

NEW YORK -- Having relocated here for the week from the home office in Los Angeles, we’ll turn out attention to the Heisman Trophy race for the first time this season.

 

With the top 10 candidates having played at least five games this season, there’s enough of a body of work to start handicapping the race to get here for the ceremony on Dec. 8, and, more importantly, all the parties that go on before and afterwards.

 

We’ll be back in three weeks to take another look at this battle royal and focus in on a survivor in this competition to be selected as college football’s most outstanding player not named Glenn Dorsey.

 

Darren McFadden, Arkansas RB
Odds to make it to Manhattan: Same as Stephon Marbury’s on a breakaway

 

It would take a Mets-esque collapse for last year’s runner-up to not make a return visit. At this pace, McFadden will finish in the neighborhood of 1,900 rushing yards and 18 touchdowns.

 

Matt Ryan, Boston College QB
Odds to make it to Manhattan: Same as a decked-out Red Sox fan finding trouble in Yonkers

 

Not since the days of Doug Flutie has there been this much excitement in Chestnut Hill and today the quarterback is bigger and better. With the Eagles off to their best start in 65 years, Ryan will be one of those rare Bostonians given a warm reception in the Big Apple.

 

Tim Tebow, Florida QB
Odds to make it to Manhattan: Same as Osi Umenyiora’s vs. Donovan McNabb

 

Sophomores don’t get invites very often, but barring injury, Tebow will systematically continue to post big numbers and produce the kind of captivating highlights that the voters like.

 

Mike Hart, Michigan RB
Odds to make it to Manhattan: Same as Senator Clinton’s in the primary

 

Not only is he consistently putting up impressive totals and exhibiting the best ball security we’ve ever seen, but Hart’s leadership and courage make him a player that’s really hard to ignore.

 

Andre' Woodson, Kentucky QB
Odds to make it to Manhattan: Same as Derek Jeter’s batting average at Tenjune

 

If the voting took place before last Thursday’s game at South Carolina, he probably would have won the darn thing. Thanks to the Gamecock pass rush and a couple errors in judgment, he’s fallen back into the middle of the pack.

 

DeSean Jackson, Cal WR-PR
Odds to make it to Manhattan: Same as the Boss’ new manager being better than Joe Torre

 

If Cal can avoid the storm of upsets hitting various parts of the country each week, Jackson will be at the center of all the hype. On the other hand, the way things are going, the Bears could also find themselves in the Holiday Bowl.

 

Chase Daniel, Missouri QB
Odds to make it to Manhattan: Same as Chad Pennington’s to make the Pro Bowl

 

Saturday’s outstanding performance in the dominating 41-6 victory over Nebraska vaulted Daniel into the mix, but this weekend’s visit to Norman could result in a short stay.

 

Colt Brennan, Hawaii QB
Odds to make it to Manhattan: Same as Britney Spears joining the cast of Wicked

 

Injuries have kept a lid on his snaps and stats, but better days ahead and an undefeated record will keep him within range until further notice. Texas Tech’s Graham Harrell is watching closely. He’ll probably finish with better numbers than Brennan, making an early case to get here in 2008.

 

Dennis Dixon, Oregon QB
Odds to make it to Manhattan: Same as A-Rod’s for being in pinstripes next season.

 

The Ducks will go as far as Dixon takes them, and vice versa. If Oregon beats USC in Eugene on Oct. 27, you can be sure that there will be a lot of SportsCenter moments provided by the ultra-athletic Duck quarterback, who’ll instantly gain lots of support.

 

John David Booty, USC QB
Odds to make it to Manhattan: Same as A.J. being capable of taking over for Tony some day

 

In the 21st century, it seemed as if it was a rite of passage for whoever was taking snaps at USC to barge into the Big Apple. But there’s been no punch to Booty’s season and Stanford knocked him out entirely.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Most of your list I agree with  but Woodson on mine would be out along with Brennan, Booty, and Dixon.If Jackson is in then I think you had better look at the stats on wide receivers and include a freshman named Michael Crabtree from Texas Tech. He could skip two games and still be laeding the field in receiving. Six games 100 yard plus( nearest other is 3 games) , 17 Touchdowns on 70 receptions(next is 55 receptions) and 1074 yards .He has to be mentioned if you mention another wide receiver....
Illinois has a running back that should be included and Steve Slaton from West Virgina.
My favorites atr Rice followed by McFadden and my Dark Horses would be the pair from Texas Tech Harrel and his freshman  marvel Crabtree
You can't include Crabtree, all the possible candidates are decided the summer before the season starts. The Heisman is about pre-season perception, not actual performance.
Give me a Break with Tim Tebow!  Am I the only one that disagrees with how great he is....NO, becuase  I have handful of friends that highly disagree he's worth a Heisman.  Not only has Florida paid for Tebow's ride but they are paying the Media to talk about him all the time.  He Plays in a difficult conference but how many other QB's in the SEC play harder than this guy?  I know a handful of quarterbacks that can outright beat him for the  award.  This season has been so inconsistent that yet the numbers are up but losses are up too!  I Know 2 conference that have been highly competetive as much as the SEC.  PAC-10 & THE BIG-10.  Besides USC (yesterday's news), Look at Oregon or Arizona State.  Rudy Carpenter, Not One loss and he's has Tebow's numbers...why isny't anyone talking about him?  Dennis Dixon..Same Story as Carpenter & Tebow. Colt Brennan, easily shattering all of their stats, but weak conference but remember BOISE ST over OKLAHOMA?  It's a damn shame!  We need these small schools play these so called big schools in neutral sites and you will get games like the Fiesta Bowl last year!  One guy that hasn't even been mentioned:  GRAHAM HARRELL (Texas Tech), 4th in QB Rating, 1st in Most Yards passed, 1st In Touchdowns Passed, and the list goes on.  I see how Tebow could be invited but not this year, maybe next!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):