ABOUT THIS BLOG

John Tamanaha

MSNBC.com contributor John Tamanaha tackles the hot topics in college football. From title contenders and Heisman hopefuls to coaches on the hot seat and recruiting battles, no issue is out of bounds.



Now entering the 'knockout stages'

Posted: Sunday, October 14, 2007 3:02 AM

After his Trojans finished off an underwhelming 20-13 victory over Arizona, Pete Carroll tried hard to sell his spin: “This was a really good day for us and a great day for everyone here at the Coliseum … just a heck of a day for us.”

 

I know that he had a much better vantage point than I did, but I wasn’t buying it. I had just witnessed the same 60 minutes of football. I saw injury-plagued USC stumble and bumble. I heard fans booing the home team for the second consecutive week. I smelled fear in the air as the Wildcats took a 13-10 lead into the fourth quarter. Surely, the Coliseum had seen much better days.

 

However, as evening faded into night, Carroll’s words transformed from garden-variety coachspeak to gospel. It was all beginning to make a lot of sense.

 

First, top-ranked LSU dropped a triple overtime 43-37 thriller at Kentucky. Then, Oregon State finished off a 31-28 victory over No. 2 California in Berkeley.

 

Les Miles and Jeff Tedford did not have a “heck of a day.” And in comparison, it really was a wonderful Saturday for USC … and Boston College, Oklahoma, South Carolina and whoever else survived another week in this shooting gallery of season.

 

So now basically everything has been reset. It’s time to start over.

 

By default, undefeated and untested Ohio State is expected to assume the precarious position at the top of the mountain when the first BCS standings are released on Sunday. And beyond the Buckeyes, South Florida and Boston College, everybody who is anybody has at least one loss to their name.

 

It used to be that you could lose early and come back into the national championship picture with some help. This year, however, there’s already been an inordinate amount of “help” being thrown around. So much so, that no more is needed. Teams just need to focus on taking care of their own business.

 

With seven weeks remaining in the season, we’re now entering the “knockout stages.” One more strike and you’re out.

 

Even the undefeated teams are included. They can’t afford to lose either. Prejudices involved with each of them won’t mix will with fresh losses when the human pollsters fill out their ballots. Things like Ohio State’s league and South Florida’s name will be hindrances.

 

But the way this wacky season has been going, it seems highly unlikely that more than two of the no-loss or one-loss teams will be able to navigate through the remainder of their schedules unscathed.  In the end, two teams will buck the trend, identify themselves and advance to the BCS Championship Game.

 

This is not to say that there won’t be any controversy. There will be a ton of that, but the contenders are now on notice and will have a fair shot to get it done in a manner that is based primarily on results.

 

So Miles and Tedford need not despair. They have as good a shot as anybody (or more specifically, Oklahoma).

 

It’ll be kind of like March Madness in the sense that it takes five consecutive victories to reach the men’s basketball national championship final. The two teams that make it to New Orleans on Jan. 7 will have to do something very similar.

 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Everyone's blaming the poor second stringer Riley at Cal today.  Why not put the blame where it really lies: a) Tedford for NOT spelling it out to the poor kid what to do BEFORE that play (if in doubt, throw it out!), and B) Cal's Defensive Coordinator (ok, U. of Oregon was tough...but hey did you come to the stadium today???).  I'm sorry...I blame the coaches!...Mike, Class of '74!
As an LSU graduate, I am grateful for Les Miles and his staff.  The dedication to the ideals of being "student athletes" permeates Coach Miles' (and his staff's) philosophy.  I love the fact that not only do they push for athletic excellence, but they also strive for individual growth and maturity. Additionally, they help to build a stronger sense of community and unity between the student athletes and the LSU community.  (Uniting and singing the LSU Alma Mater at the conclusion of home games with the Golden Band from Tigerland can bring tears as the song trails  to the final phrase ... "forever LSU!")  LSU is on the march to surpass is stature as the state's flagship university into one of national prominence.  Coach Miles and his staff are assisting in that endeavor by showcasing athletically and academically talented young men and on a national stage.  The true measure of sportsmanship is exhibited in the humility of victory and re-dedication to fundamentals and focus in defeat.  I am a proud Tiger regardless!  GEAUX TIGERS!  Dick R. Trahan, Class of `75 (Honolulu, Hawai`i)
Any win right now by USC should be considered a good win considering the state of the team.

Consider that in the Arizona game they were playing without about 8 starters, most of whom are All American type guys.  

On defense, Pinkard, Cushing and Malaluga all were gone as well as some back up corners.

On offense, Booty, the 2 best rb's Johnson and Gable, and the OL is an absolute mess! 3 of the starters are out, and the 2 best guys left are playing with severe hand injuries. Throw in a coupld back ups now out and a thin group to begin with is hanging by a thread.

How many teams around the country would look real impressive playing without almost half of their projected starters?  None.
John, good piece of writing. I don't think I have ever witnessed a season like this year. With all the aberrant games played it makes you wonder. The BCS game will have two teams that have an early loss on their record. Still it bothers me that all the bleeding hearts out there are willing to vote some of these schools above true traditional football schools.
Two weeks in a row there were great - what you call - knock-out games in the Pac-10.  But how many people were able to see them on the Versus network?  Probably only the people looking for hockey or cycling.  
At the beginning of the season, the west coast reporters were calling this USC team the best in the history of college football.
How quickly they abandoned the Trojans.  I'm not a USC fan (quite the contrary), but these are still college kids, under intense pressure.  The media must give them a break.
I'm seeing a bunch of better coaches and better staff's, better recruiting and just a bunch of better teams, this has been growing for many years and many of these coaches have roots in the NFL.

Collage football will only get better and the BCS will come to mean nothing as it should. It was and is a step in the right direction to a national collage play off series.

Imagine a sweet sixteen on 1 Dec with the best of the best on new years day. Now we're getting somewhere. No what if's, no rankings, just win or lose, and a cinderella team could win the whole thing, lock stock and barrel.

I look forward to the day!!!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):