ABOUT THIS BLOG

John Tamanaha

MSNBC.com contributor John Tamanaha tackles the hot topics in college football. From title contenders and Heisman hopefuls to coaches on the hot seat and recruiting battles, no issue is out of bounds.



Possible BCS scenarios

Posted: Monday, November 12, 2007 3:14 AM

 

Thanks to Juice Williams and Ron Zook, the various possibilities for the BCS Championship Game have come into clearer focus.  There are still several ways that this could end up, but the following is a rundown of the five most likely matchups for Jan. 7.

 

LSU vs. Oregon

This would be the classic “Les Miles vs. the Pac-10” grudge match that we thought we’d be treated to from the beginning, minus USC, of course.  Instead, the Ducks would have the responsibility of trying to teach the tough-talking Tiger coach about the strength of football along the West Coast.  Unfortunately for Oregon, it would have to do so in LSU’s backyard.  And that wouldn’t be the only difficulty.  Facing a menacing defense that can run with them and a battering ram offense that isn’t afraid to use fourth down wouldn’t be easy.

 

Why it could happen:  These two leaders have what it takes to hold serve.

 

Why it wouldn’t:  “The Civil War” with Oregon State has a bloody history.  So does the SEC Championship Game.

 

Who’d be favored (according to last week’s power rankings):  LSU by 4.

 

LSU vs. Oklahoma

 Those who seek the most “traditional” title bout would prefer to see it end up this way.  The Tigers and Sooners have accounted for nine national titles, while the other four teams within the BCS Standings’ top six have combined for none.  It would really be a treat to see Miles and Bob Stoops go toe-to-toe once again.  Even though he never finished higher than third in the Big 12 South when he was the top Cowboy at Oklahoma State, Miles split his four games against Stoops.

 

Why it could happen:  Oregon doesn’t have a good history with regard to the BCS.

 

Why it wouldn’t:  The BCS formula has been changed slightly since Oregon got screwed in 2001.

 

Who’d be favored:  LSU by 1.

 

Oklahoma vs. Oregon

The Sooners would finally get their rematch with the Ducks.  But this time far, far away from Eugene and the Pac-10 officials who blew the call on that fateful onside kick on Sept. 16, 2006.  The massive collection of offensive weaponry under one roof would be awe inspiring.  Sam Bradford, DeMarco Murray, Malcolm Kelly, Dennis Dixon and Jonathan Stewart would make for great television.

 

Why it could happen:  You heard it first from Les Miles himself, the SEC route to this game is just too tough.

 

Why it wouldn’t:  LSU is so strong (or lucky) it doesn’t even need to be at its best to lock up one of the top two spots.

 

Who’d be favored:  Oklahoma by 3.

 

LSU vs. Kansas

The Cinderella Jayhawks would likely be facing their third consecutive Top-5 foe.  The Tigers, as Miles would like everybody to know, would be staring at their 11th elite opponent (Virginia Tech gets grouped in with the almighty SEC).  But, no matter what you believe, the fact remains that this pair would have played teams such as Central Michigan, Southeastern Louisiana, Toledo, Florida International, Middle Tennessee State, Tulane and Louisiana Tech on their way to meeting up at the Superdome.  More of Mark Mangino is always a good thing (you know what I mean) and America would really enjoy getting know him better.

 

Why it could happen:  It’s Mangino’s world.  We’re just orbiting it.

 

Why it wouldn’t:  Conference title games can be a bitch.

 

Who’d be favored:  LSU by 5.

 

Kansas vs. Oregon

 The executives at FOX won’t be happy if this matchup materializes.  One team without a heavy-duty heritage can be interesting.  Two is a ratings disaster.

 

Why it could happen:  It has been that kind of year.  Why not?

 

Why it wouldn’t:  Lou Holtz seems determined to jinx the Jayhawks by continuing to proclaim them No. 1.

 

Who’d be favored:  Oregon by 1.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

"LSU vs. Kansas: The Cinderella Wildcats would likely be facing their third consecutive Top-5 foe."  

Kansas U is the Jayhawks, and Kansas State is the Wildcats.  
"The Cinderella Wildcats"?  Do you guys have an editor?
Come on, John. Learn your top 10 teams. KU is the Jayhawks, not the Wildcats. The Wildcats are the ones who got creamed by Nebraska this weekend. For K-State to be in this position would truly make them a Cinderella team.
Cinderella Jayhawks, rather?
You called them the Cinderella "Wildcats" not the Jayhawks!  Everyone should love the Jayhawks, and the way they are playing they could beat anyone in the nation, believe it.
Cinderella Wildcats?  Did you really just refer to KU as the "Wildcats?"  LSU is the Tigers, and the tiger is, technically, a "Wildcat" but your use of the term "Cinderella" makes me pretty sure you were referring to the University of Kansas, commonly known as the "Jayhawks."

As a lifelong KU fan, please accept my thanks for giving KU another "no respect" card to play.  Heck, if the national media can't get them right after THIS season, it might take KU winning out to finally get the respect, and name recognition, they deserve.
Jayhawks = National Champions
Cinderella Wildcats?  Did you really just refer to KU as the "Wildcats?"  LSU is the Tigers, and the tiger is, technically, a "Wildcat" but your use of the term "Cinderella" makes me pretty sure you were referring to the University of Kansas, commonly known as the "Jayhawks."

As a lifelong KU fan, please accept my thanks for giving KU another "no respect" card to play.  Heck, if the national media can't get them right after THIS season, it might take KU winning out to finally get the respect, and name recognition, they deserve.
Hey John, if you're going to be writing a blog about potential matchups for the national championship game, I would suggest you get the team names correct. It is the Kansas JAYHAWKS, not Wildcats.
The KU mascot is a Jayhawk, not a Wildcat.  Wildcats are from Kansas State (as well as countless other uncreative schools like Arizona, Kentucky, Northwester, etc.).
It's the Jayhawks, not the Wildcats, jackass.
I only have one thing to say.  DUH!  you put out some of the most pointless information on the web.  Let me make your prediction more basic.  Someone ranked 1-4 will likely be playing someones ranked 1-4 in the BCS Title game.  

If you guys need a staff writer give me a call
just who are the Cinderella Wildcats in the Kansas/LSU matchup? Are they related to the Duke Tar Heels? Miami Seminoles? Michigan Buckeyes? or maybe the Georgia Crimson Tide. Granted college football bloggers wouldn't know too much about the University of Kansas, but the JAYHAWKS have been in the sports pages before. Go check the basketball bloggers, they know who Kansas is.
Hey buddy - hope your prognostications are better than your mascot knowledge - Kansas is the *Jayhawks*, not the Wildcats...
Kansas isn't the wildcats - that's Kansas State - get it right - they are the Jayhawks!
Are you serious?  The Cinderella Wildcats?  I don't think the Kansas State Wildcats have much hope for a National Title game.  However, the Kansas Jayhawks are looking pretty good.  Do you actually get paid to give your thoughts on sports?  KU probably won't make it to the title game, but you still need to show some respect man!
Either no one reads this blog or the "Wildcats" are as unknown as is claimed.  I'd rather see a KU/UO game than have to suffer through another night of "the sweater vest" pacing the sidelines.  For non-basketball fans and those not living in the Sunflower state, KU are the Jayhawks.  
If Kansas wins out and gets shut out...WOW.
Kansas is the Jayhawks...not the Wildcats!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11
When will you Idiots learn Kansas State is the Wildcats not Kansas. Kansas's mascott is the Jayhawk.
You really don't know much about football its the Kansas Jayhawks not the wildcats.  I'll make sure I never read any of this guys work again.  Don't you read your work before you put it out.
I was wondering who the Cinderella Wildcats are who is referred to in the Kansas-LSU matchup. Are they in the same conference as the Duke Tar Heels, or USC Bruins, or maybe the Buckeyes of Michigan. Granted, the JAYHAWKS of KANSAS arent usually on the radar screen of college football bloggers, still they have been on the sports pages a lot over the past 50 years. Dont football bloggers pay attention to basketball?
Kansas are not the Wildcats, they are the Jayhawks.
"The Cinderella Wildcats"???  Indicative of SEC/Pac10 bias.  You don't even know the mascot of the sole undefeated BCS conference team!
The Cinderella Wildacts??!  I know we don't have a great football tradition, but at number four in the country I would hope someone would realize that we are the Jayhawks.
I read your article by accident. It won't happen again. Since you are incapable of getting the teams right, I don't think you know what you are talking about. It's not Kansas Wildcats, its Kansas Jayhawks. Your not much of a writer if you don't know that. At least hire a proofreader if your not good enough to do it yourself.
LSU still has to beat either Georgia or Tennessee, and that ain't gonna happen. Kansas will not beat both Mizzou & Oklahoma; Oregon is a lock, and I think they'll be playing Oklahome. USC will be playing LSU (what a game...can't wait to see Miles pull his foot out of his , er, mouth).
"The Cinderella Wildcats" huh....

Last time I checked, the mascot for the University of Kansas is the "Jayhawk".  

Let me guess, you never played sports...you just right about them.  Good work.
In your segment "LSU vs. Kansas" you have referred to Kansas as the "Cinderalla Wildcats".  The University of Kansas are the Jayhawks.  The Wildcats hail from Kansas State University.  And you call yourselves professionals?  Do your homework!
Can you at least get the correct mascot for Kansas - the Jayhawks, not the cinderella wildcats.
LSU vs. Kansas...ok, so that might happen, however, it's the "cinderella JAYHAWKS, not cinderella Wildcats...wow you really wanna stir up some angry KU fans with that slip of the tongue???? haha...that happened at their last home game, the referee when announcing a penalty over the PA system said, "first down Kansas State." The crown booed him mercilessly!
In the LSU vs Kansas,  you didn't refer to Kansas as the Wildcats did you?  
You might want to re-check your mascots under the LSU vs. Kansas paragraph.   There are no Cinderella Wildcats, only Cinderella Jayhawks!
Dear John...does you "fanhood" need questioning?
We're the Cinderella Jayhawks, not the Cinderella Wildcats.
Really, the "Cinderella Wildcats" from Kansas?  MSNBC.com should really look into hiring a fact checker for these articles if they are going to continue to employ writers like Tamanha.  Go Jayhawks.
The Cinderella Wildcats???  What kind of a sports journalist doesn't know KU are the Jayhawks?  I know they're new to the national football scene, but come on.  You've gotta at least know that from basketball.  
of course a die hard dawg fan, but gotta keep the title in the SEC no matter what. I am one that thinks no other conf. can play a SEC team week after week and still have 2 loses or less.....go dawgs
Let's not forget LSU still has to play Mississippi State and Arkansas as the SEC Championship Game which right now looks like it's going to be against Georgia or maybe Tennesee.

Kansas still has Mizzou and more than likely Texas or OU in the Big 12 Championship.  Based on the crazy weeks we have seen already this year...Anything can happen!!
I like the way most people are already overlooking the LSU vs. MSU and the LSU vs. AR games.

 Also OU still has Texas Tech and Oklahoma State...please do not overlook these games in your post season predictions.   Not to mention LSU's postseason record..they've won 5 of their last 7, while OU has Lost 3 of it's last 5...(including that huge upset to Boise State last season) So even if both teams win out...LSU has a sustantial edge over OU.
the gators are #1
If LSU goes 2-0 in it's next couple of games, I don't care who we play as long as it's not Florida. My body can't stand another one of those contests.

Their one tough bunch of guys. No slight to the others meant.
Yo Tamahahaha!

You said USC would beat Oregon.  Not!
You said Arizona State would beat Oregon. Not!

You're one of the very few, outside of the Oklahoma state capitol, still bringing up a blown call from Sept, 2006.

How on earth did you ever get a job covering any kind of sport, much less college football?

Try covering any sport you actually played in school so we don't have to read you any more.
Ok guys so what happens if Mizzou thumps KU and gets a win against OU in the Big 12 Championship? That would put a twist in things... Reality, OU- LSU
It aint over till it's over.There have been plenty of upsets and we still have a few weeks left.
PREDICTIONS just that,like the preseason polls.

LET'S'S'S'S'S GO,O,O,O, MOUNTAINEERS'S'S'S'S'!!!!!!!!!
It will be Oklahoma vs Oregon for the BCS National Championship. LSU will lose in the SEC Title Game, OU will beat Kansas in the Big 12 Championship, and Oregon will win out their regular season!! All is said and done,

OKLAHOMA  VS  OREGON
Kansas Will Beat Missouri and Oklahoma finishing the season 13-0 going into the title came against Oregon were the will edge out a talented ducks squad 52-49!
ROCK CHALK JAYHAWK!!
You can all stop dithering, It will be LSU against some cupcake like Oregon, Kansas or St Cecila's girls field hocky team  but certainly not a quality  team that inhabits the SEC!
MIZZOU ALL THE WAY
West Virginia baby


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):