ABOUT THIS BLOG

John Tamanaha

MSNBC.com contributor John Tamanaha tackles the hot topics in college football. From title contenders and Heisman hopefuls to coaches on the hot seat and recruiting battles, no issue is out of bounds.



USC turns attention to QB battle

Posted: Sunday, March 23, 2008 3:58 PM

A year after advancing to the Sweet 16 and despite the presence of O.J. Mayo, the USC men’s basketball team wasn’t able to even get out of the first round of the NCAA Tournament. The sting is still in the air, but Tim Floyd doesn’t have to worry. It won’t last long.

Spring practice is just about here.

Football -- even if just the spring version -- supersedes everything at USC.

Anything else, no matter how upsetting, falls quickly into a dimly-lit background. And that’s especially the case at this moment in time, which is a little different for the Trojan footballers.

It has been a long time since Pete Carroll and his legions of fans haven’t known who their starting quarterback will be.

During this century, USC’s field general has been someone named either Carson Palmer, Matt Leinart or John David Booty. Not a bad trio, creating quite a comfort zone as a team enters a season.

It’s not that USC doesn’t have a suitable successor to Booty for the 2008 campaign.  Actually, it’s quite the opposite. The Trojans have more than one.

Los Angeles is no stranger to quarterback controversies. Dating back to the days when the Rams had a pair of Hall of Famers in Bob Waterfield and Norm Van Brocklin, Los Angeles had more quality QB quandaries than any other city.

This latest one features Mark Sanchez and Mitch Mustain. All eyes will be on that duo as they share the snaps during USC’s spring drills, which begin on Tuesday.

Sanchez, a junior who signed with USC out of high school, has been with the program longer. He even started three games last season after Booty broke a finger. So, if there needs to be a frontrunner, you can consider him slightly ahead.

But Mustain, a sophomore who redshirted last season after transferring from Arkansas, is sure to get a long look from Carroll and his staff during the Trojans’ 15 practice sessions. As a true freshman in 2006, Mustain was 8-0 as a starter for the Razorbacks.

Even on the West Coast, where fans don’t automatically regard the SEC as the nation’s elite conference, Mustain’s undefeated mark as a starter at Arkansas has people talking. Perhaps they even remember his sensational collegiate debut when he came off the bench and mopped up for the Hogs against USC in the 2006 season opener for both schools.

The score was already 44-7 in favor of the Trojans when Mustain entered the game and he wasn’t going against all of USC’s first-teamers, but his first drive was a thing of beauty. It even included a 42-yard pass completion to Damian Williams, a fellow true freshman at the time who also transferred to USC. And after completing all three of his passes, Mustain provided the exclamation point with a slick four-yard touchdown run.

USA Today’s “National Player of the Year” in 2005, Mustain was an absolute Arkansas cult hero while at Springdale High School. He was even rated by many to be a better college prospect than Tim Tebow.

Sanchez has a similar pedigree. He was the 2004 Parade Magazine “Player of the Year,” and the jewel of Carroll’s 2005 recruiting class, which also featured linebackers Rey Maualuga and Brian Cushing, and wide receiver Patrick Turner.

But, Sanchez might actually have a little less to hang his helmet on as he enters spring ball. He was 2-1 as starter last season. Sanchez’s victories came against Arizona (USC had to rally to win, 20-13, at the Coliseum) and Notre Dame (four touchdown passes), which aren’t exactly a pair of world-beaters. The loss was a 24-17 setback at then-No. 2 Oregon, which came to an end when Sanchez threw his second interception of the fourth quarter in the final moments.

Actually, if that game had ended differently, we wouldn’t be having this conversation. Sanchez would have raised his stock considerably and one-loss USC (the Trojans dropped that shocker at home to Stanford three weeks prior to their loss in Eugene) would have probably played for and won the national championship.

Under that scenario, Carroll would have likely rewarded Sanchez for his role in bringing another title to USC and Mustain would have had to wait his turn, like Booty did behind Leinart.

But here we are with a good ol’ fashion quarterback controversy at the top of the collegiate football food chain.

Ah … spring time.  Don’t you just love it?

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

This is typical west coast media bias blather.  "If USC could have/would hav won game X, Y, or Z, they would have played in and won the national champianship game"  When are the USC appologists going to give it a rest. It is pothetically obvious that you guys are hopelessly blind.
I also think Sanchez put himself in Pete Carroll's doghouse with that allegeded rape accusation, ala Hershel Dennis.  PC likes "good character" guys leading his team.  It's all part of the USC image...even guys like Leinart and Bush knew how to play that part, when they were here.  "Dirty Sanchez" has cleaned up his act, but PC never forgets...  He was forced to use Sanchez when Booty was hurt, reluctant to the point of letting Booty play dispite a broken finger that may of cost them the Stanford game.  PC couldn't wait for Booty to get healthy and back in the starting QB spot.  

In the past, PC has always named a starting QB out of spring practice, despite his "open competition".  He always favors the "incumbant".  However, if Sanchez doesn't come out of spring practice with that title, look for PC to pin Mustain as his unofficial starting QB.  Once Mustain gets the job, he ain't going to let it go.  I think he's got the skills, mindset and leadership quality to be the #1 guy for USC.  

You gotta love a guy that leaves a starting job at a college where he was a high school legend to challenge himself and put himself in a position to compete for a National Championship.  

Look for #16 Mustain to lead our men to victory...Fight-On!
Anybody who knows Pete Carroll knows that he never names anybody an automatic starter.  Sanchez could have beaten LSU in the BCS title game and he (Carroll) still would have said that Sanchez will have to earn the spot next year.  
Hi football fans,
Well John!! Its not long now. Remember what you said about UGA? Were you playing the part, are were you for real? I still think that you were right on, so don't let us down. Every year we get closer. Lets make it happen. This season belongs to UGA, and a lot of the greatest fans anywhere !!!

Bily
Hello,
I just wanted to thank John, for saying he thought Georgia would be a very good team, and had a chance of playing for the National Title. Thanks John, and keep up the great sports talk.
Thanks John,
A very good piece on USC. Its so good, that spring practice is just about here. I also enjoyed your kind words about UGA. Keep the great sports coming, and football will be here soon. Thanks again,

Billy
Healthy problems to have and add the RB train they have stocked this team is looking to be in great shape.  Injuries proved to be the difference (although they should not have mattered in the Stanford Loss).  This is an interesting turning point for a program that you would think has already turned a few corners.  This years team has a lot to prove and with all the returning experience and the QB competition this should be a wild spring and summer session.  Too bad CFB isn't year round.  Or is it?
John,

I wholeheartedly agree with your assessment on the QB battle at SC. However, everyone should not count out Aaron Corp. He is as good, if not better, than Sanchez and Mustain.
Clearly the author doesn't comprehend the difference between competition and controversy.

No one owns the spot at the start of the year, not in QB, not in any position, they are all up for grabs.
Clearly M.Sanchez has the inside track.

This is just another case of media, trying to stir up a story.
USC is the best team by far, we get the best players every year, and PC does a good job putting the team together whether old are new. Fight on SC.
The best QB will win the job. Pete doesn't get personal nor is he political about it. If Mark is better, he will play. Same goes for Mitch and Aaron. USC will have a stellar QB on that field this fall, no matter who it is. Competition brings out the best, and the best will lead the Trojans!
How quickly do we forget! As much as I love Matt Leinard, we also had Matt Cassel as a junior who would have started the season if he did not have the flue the week prior to the season opener - and most likely we would never have known about Matt Leinard - and I am glad we did.
Mark Sanchez will do well - I expect it and Mustain will have to wait for his turn as Mark and John David have - that's the price you have to pay to play the position at USC.
Thank you coach Caroll - this is a good problem to have!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):