ABOUT THIS BLOG

John Tamanaha

MSNBC.com contributor John Tamanaha tackles the hot topics in college football. From title contenders and Heisman hopefuls to coaches on the hot seat and recruiting battles, no issue is out of bounds.



Pac-10 is league of the weak, and other 'Extra Points'

Posted: Sunday, September 14, 2008 3:25 PM

While wondering if Charlie Weis would be willing to sacrifice a pair of ligaments in return for a victory every Saturday, this week’s set of EXTRA POINTS begins out West where things are upside-down for the moment.

 

League of the week: The Mountain West won all but one of its non-conference games on Saturday, including a sterling 4-0 mark against teams from the Pac-10, which is usually the undisputed bully of the region. The only setback for the MWC was San Diego State’s 35-10 loss at San Jose State, which is apparently a much tougher place to play than South Bend.

 

BCS league of the week: For the first time in history, Southeastern Conference schools occupy half of the Associated Press Top-10. Furthermore, based on the total number of points available in the poll (20,800), the SEC represents 29.6 percent (6,150) of this week’s AP Top-25. Not too shabby.

 

League of the weak: Aside from USC, what does the Pac-10 have? If going by recent results … not much. I’m thinking that it’s a certainty that this conference will have more fired coaches than Bowl Championship Series participants. 

Tale of one city: And then there’s UCLA. Before the season, the Bruins took out bold newspaper ads, proclaiming that “The football monopoly in Los Angeles is officially over.” That seemed like a possibility after the Bruin coaching staff used an array of mirrors to beat Tennessee on Labor Day. But the monopoly seems to be as strong as ever in both Los Angeles and Provo after BYU undressed UCLA, 59-0.

 

Has there ever been starker contrast between the Bruins and their crosstown rival Trojans based on the result of a single Saturday?

 

At least until further notice, USC is clearly THE University of Southern California. But we won’t go as far as the Los Angeles Times, which ran a huge headline on Sunday morning that screamed: “Miami beachhead,” and book hotel rooms on South Beach just yet for the Trojans.

 

More Trojans: After solidifying themselves as THE Ohio State University with wins over Youngstown State and Ohio, the Buckeyes will try to go 1-1 versus Trojan squads when they host Troy at the Horseshoe on Saturday. It will be interesting to gauge how many of those Buckeye helmet stickers were given out in the postmortem of the 35-3 disaster at USC. Terrelle Pryor deserves at least a couple (and some additional playing time), but we’re not sure who else.

 

Pitcher’s duel in Starkville: Oddities like Auburn’s 3-2 win at Mississippi State are part of what makes college football so special. There’s no truth to the rumor that Tim Hudson pitched five strong innings and Frank Thomas provided the winning margin with a solo shot in the top of the ninth.

 

Next up for Tommy Tuberville is the Tiger-Tiger showdown at LSU. Last year, the teams combined for 54 points and 784 total yards in LSU’s dramatic last-second victory. We might not see totals half as large in what will be this week’s marquee matchup, which will surely be more interesting than last Saturday’s supposed “Game of the Year” at the Coliseum.

 

A round of applause please: How about David Cutcliffe leading Duke to a pair of victories within his first three games in Durham? That’s how many wins the Blue Devils have had in their previous three seasons combined. We’re not sure how many more will follow now that they’ll be getting into conference play, but the 41-31 victory over Navy was impressive and the pass-catch combo of Thaddeus Lewis and Eron Riley is the best one you’ve never heard of.

 

Stand up and boo: If the current malaise of the Syracuse program wasn’t bad enough, Saturday’s 55-13 pounding applied by Penn State came against a backdrop of the Orange’s glorious past. What must Orangeman legends such as Jim Brown and Floyd Little be thinking the day after they gathered for the world premiere of “The Express,” a movie about Ernie Davis, who led Syracuse to an undefeated season in 1959 and won the Heisman Trophy two years later?

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

MWC wins 4 out of 4 against Pac 10 and pac 10 is conference of the week?
It's a crying shame that the Mountain West Conference is left out of the BCS Money behind the ACC and the Big East- maybe even the PAC-10.  I will be disappointed if BYU plays Wake Forest in the Orange Bowl.
Pac 10 is very good. The Mt West Conference just better this week. Love to see what the Mt west conf. would have done to the SEC. Over-rated conference as well.
The reality is football has changed with the new NCAA rules, recruiting and scholarships to the point that any team could be dangerous wether in the BCS or not.

The BCS conf. just don't have the same dominance.

Predict BYU in the top 5 if not playing against USC or an SEC team or perhaps BIG12.
Oklahoma looking better this year. Quality team that can compete like USC and Florida etc.

Not going to guarantee that as the underdogs will play hard against any of these teams mentioned. Expect upsets this year.

Favor BYU because they have a killer offense and a strong defense. Not the best but who cares with the special teams plays they have.
They have by far the best kicker in the NCAA and NFL.

Freshman sorenson is deadly at any range...70 + yd field goal kicker. Wow!
NFL after him already.

Anytime special teams can keep the other team deep in their territory...makes it easit for the Offense and the defense. Any other words, UCLA didn't stand a chance!
Washington got lucky but played good D at the goal line against BYU. Gave them that surge at the end of the game. Minus that mistake and BYU was running up the score another 21pts.
All about position and taking care of the ball. IF USC and Florida get too agressive they will start to fumble and you will see them getting upset. All for an extra yard. players need to protect the ball.

Other teams have yet to emerge this season that are still undefeated and will most likely climb into contention.

Because the SEC and the BIG 12 have Championship games....I doubt any team will go undefeated.

PAC 10 has good teams so it is questionable if USC will survive but I think they will. Very good team that is well coached. So much talent that they make get cockey and party too much. Seen it happen to the best and then they lose to haples teams like STANFORD.

Injury will always change our predictions so will see how healthy each team will stay as the season has just started.

Oh...saw the plenalty in the BYU/WASH game and it was a penalty that would not have changed the outcome of the game. STUPID RULE but in the end the huskies got blocked. Would not have survuved OT either.
You would have lost you money gambling on that one.
CHECK THE STATS...BYU was putting the huskies in stanglehold.
I feel bad for TYRONE W. Probably get fired. Good coach that is dealing with a messed up program.




You should do some research before posting comments about the Buckeye stickers.  If the team does not win, nobody receives a Helmet Sticker.
Hey.  At least Oregon State won this past week.
The Pac-10 overall is down this year. I was extremely disappointed by ASU looking ahead to Georgia. That would have been an awesome game that could have done wonders for ASU recruiting. Now USC will continue to get the pick of who they want from the desert (not that they have to recruit there). Being an alum from Wazzu it saddens me to see how far the program has fallen. Too many bad scholarships to punks that had no right wearing the Cougs uniform. Already at a huge disadvantage in trying to recruit it doesn't help now that our reputation has been tarnished.

Last comment... Fight on USC, stay focused and I see another national championship in your future.

Transplated Pac-10 to the left coast. By the way there are a ton of Pac-10 alum here in the Washington DC northern Virgina area.

Go PAC-10!
USC is truly the cream of the West, and I would agree that Carroll's recruiting has caused the Pac10 to be lopsided...I would hope they can take care of Pac10 business this year. There is NO question the SEC has more beef overall than any other conference...only SEC fans can appreciate that 3-2 masterpiece between Aub-MSU. The Gators are playing well, and barring injuries and turnovers (that would be 0 so far), we can make the drive to Miami and introduce USC to the SEC...Go Gators!!!
It was conference of the "WEAK".  Yeah the SEC is overatted. That's why they destroy everyone in non conference play and bowl games..lol Pac 10 has always been overatted just for the fact that it makes USC look better.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):