ABOUT THIS BLOG

John Tamanaha

MSNBC.com contributor John Tamanaha tackles the hot topics in college football. From title contenders and Heisman hopefuls to coaches on the hot seat and recruiting battles, no issue is out of bounds.



Drama-free BCS title game possible

Posted: Sunday, November 09, 2008 7:29 AM

While wondering how Wyoming coach Joe Glenn is 15-29 within the MWC, but 3-1 versus the SEC, we’re back to sort out the happenings in Week 11 of the college football season.

 

Big Ten-less BCS title game: Even though it wasn’t the one that rolled over in the past two national championship games, Penn State would have carried the albatross of Ohio State’s failings if it had played in this season’s BCS title game, guilty by conference association. But thanks to Daniel Murray, Iowa’s backup kicker, it looks like Dolphin Stadium will be Big Ten free on Jan. 8. Murray’s 31-yard field goal with one second remaining Saturday lifted the Hawkeyes to a 24-23 victory over the Nittany Lions, who would be poised to make a title game appearance if the kick was off the mark and they closed the season with a pair of expected home victories. If Penn State had continued to matriculate toward the big game, we would have been subjected to all sorts of doom-and-gloom predictions describing how the Big Ten champions would go down in flames once again in the main event. With that out of the way, we can focus on a wide variety of controversial BCS subject matter, all of which is more interesting.

 

The “we-all-agree scenario” is alive and well: Although it wouldn’t be as much fun without all the associated bickering, there is a possibility that we could be headed to a championship pairing that’s non-speculative. With only two undefeated teams still standing among the chosen six conferences, there is hope that we won’t need that concoction of polls and computers to settle upon a pair of worthy teams. Alabama (10-0) needs to avoid stubbing its toe in home games versus Mississippi State and Auburn (a combined 3-8 in league play) and then “upset” lower-ranked Florida in the SEC Championship Game. Texas Tech (10-0) has a similar gauntlet, needing to win at Oklahoma in a couple weeks, beat Baylor at home, then prevail in the Big 12 title game. History tells us we’d be lucky to see even one of those teams make it through unscathed. But stranger things have happened, and Nick Saban vs. Mike Leach would make for an interesting week in South Florida.

 

Our new Top 10:

No. 1 – Texas Tech (no late-game heroics required this time)

No. 2 – Alabama (LSU had its shot to bounce ‘Bama)

No. 3 – Florida (how did these guys lose to Ole Miss?)

No. 4 – Texas (needs miracle to win Big 12 South)

No. 5 – Oklahoma (takes this week off after routing A&M)

No. 6 – USC (“D” making much better use of talent than “O”)

No. 7 – Penn State (now in a battle for Rose Bowl berth)

No. 8 – Utah (“Holy War” vs. BYU awaits Nov. 22)

No. 9 – Boise State (computers will hurt Broncos chances)

No. 10 – Ohio State (Pryor practically a sophomore now)

 

Harrell Heisman: A week after pumping up his resume with the required “Heisman highlight moment,” Texas Tech quarterback Graham Harrell went back to work on those gaudy numbers. In the Red Raiders’ 56-20 victory over Oklahoma State on Saturday, he was 40-of-50 for 456 yards and six touchdowns. Harrell has thrown for 4,077 yards and 36 scores.  In addition, he has more rushing touchdowns (six) than interceptions (five). With Oklahoma and Baylor pass defenses ranking way down at Nos. 90 and 102, respectively, one can expect Harrell’s production to hold steady and keep him at the front of the pack, fending off a late charge by the reigning Heisman winner Tim Tebow.

 

Quiet week ahead:  Although this past week brought an added touch of clarity to the top of the BCS picture, the upcoming slate isn’t likely to do the same. Other than possibly sorting out the muddled ACC (Virginia Tech at Miami on Thursday, and Boston College at Florida State and North Carolina at Maryland on Saturday), don’t expect anything too noteworthy.  The most excitement will be in Gainesville, where the Ol’ Ball Coach will be trying to find a way to get his Gamecocks in position to foul up Florida.  Wouldn’t that be something?

 

 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I do not think you should move Florida in front of Texas.  They came within 1 second of beating TT.
Harrell as a Hesiman leader is a joke. Quarterbacks in that system always rack up huge numbers,(similar to Hawaii QBs in the past. He hits easy wide open receivers and doesn't make plays with his legs. Colt McCoy seems to make plays when his team needs it with his arm and legs and makes his team mates better. Similar to Tebow last year. His team lost because of defense and led because of him.
I'm a former SEC football player at Auburn. I do not think Alabama should be ranked #1. This team will be 2nd in the SEC. Florida is the best team in the SEC and probably the nation. They will crush Bama in the SEC Title game.
The more likely "we-all-agree scenario" is that Florida wins out.  Despite the Gators' one loss, defeating No. 1 ranked Alabama to win the SEC would inarguably put them in the Nationsl Championship Game.
Why would ANYONE put Florida above Oklahoma or Texas? Oklahoma and Texas lost to GOOD team in competitive games, on either neutral sites or on the road. Florida lost to Ole Miss at HOME. Furthermore, USC should be above Florida, too. Losing to Oregon State on the road AND giving up only 60 points on the entire season so far?

Please. The SEC love affair that has fixed the last two BCS title games needs to end NOW.
Drama free? What a farce. Here's how the season will finish...

Florida loses to South Carolina, Destroys Florida State, and wins the SEC championship.

Texas Tech wins out, but loses to Mizzou in the Big 12 title game.

Oregon State runs the table to win the Pac 10 title. (setting up a rematch with Penn State in the Rose Bowl)

Now you have all sorts of drama for the title game. (who knows, if it all plays out like this, maybe MSNBC will hire me todo predictions.)
CFB is a biased sport. That is obvious to fans for the most part and even the media. In relevant as we know the omnious BCS like subjectivity and controversy more then $$$ (money).
Could make alot more with a playoff. right now we have a 2 system playoff that can't pick the top 2 teams because people can manipulate the results by how they vote. THATS FRAUD!
Why no lawsuit?
Right now, why is USC ranked ahead of UTAH?
UTAH is undefeated and beat oregon st that beat USC. Plus the MT West conference is hot this year. Put a major beating on all the other conferences and particulary the PAC10. The few loses by Mt West teams were rather close as ND pulled out a victory over SDSU.
There is alot of people that favored USC and still do apparently including myself. Just pointing out how ridiculous it is that BCS conf get favored over teams that are actually better and have proven it on the field of play.
Pete Carol and perterno and Meyer and all the coaches would prefer a playoff. They all know that the system is flawed. The flaws virtually go away if we expanded from a 2 playoff format to atleast 10. Love wierd numbers because then we have to have play-in added to it. The reality is 8 team playoff cover most issues. Just go 16 and then there is no question mathematically for complaint unless we get more conferences and teams that could run the table.

My premise is that any undefeated team shares a claaim as national champion by virtue that no challenger could beat them.
Only 1 team shall stand undefeated.
Amen for the SEC love affair.  Sure they are rabid fans.  Sure they have close games.  And yes. every year (just like nearly EVERY major conference) they have a couple good teams. Great football and teh Sec are NOT mutually exclusive.  Being a stone cold NOTRE DAME fan, living in the South, I don't "have a dog in this fight" but, if I can't get a break from the dream like fantasy about the SEC, at least allow the courtesy of a reality check.  Not for me but the rest of the country who loves to see a grea college football game.  
sol frank, your an idiot. who cares how texas lost. the point is they lost. and just like florida by one point. look at what the gators have done since. destroying georgia, lsu, kentucky,vandy, and south carolina. all of who were ranked in the top 25 at the time . except for kentucky. who has texas played since. kansas? kansas cant even tie their own shoes this year. do the research and pay more attention before you make a commint that is stupid.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):