ABOUT THIS BLOG

John Tamanaha

MSNBC.com contributor John Tamanaha tackles the hot topics in college football. From title contenders and Heisman hopefuls to coaches on the hot seat and recruiting battles, no issue is out of bounds.



Florida heads list of teams you don't want to face

Posted: Sunday, November 16, 2008 7:39 AM

While trying to get used to this new era of change that has Vanderbilt headed to a bowl game, Michigan staring at a nine-loss season and a President-elect already pushing for a playoff, we’re back to see where the rest of the college football world stands after Week 12.

 

The ones you don’t want to play: Because upsets have suddenly become scarce and a “traditional” Top 10 wouldn’t get shuffled much this week -- if at all -- let’s try something new.  Below you’ll find our “teams you wouldn’t want to play” Top 10.  Here’s the squads we’d least like to face on a neutral field right now, ranked in order of fear factor.

 

1 – Florida (who would want to mess with these Gators)

2 – Texas Tech (outscoring them is the ultimate challenge)

3 – Alabama (Nick Saban will find a way to beat you)

4 – Oklahoma (spent bye week resting offensive machine)

5 – Texas (yes, we’d rather lock horns here than with Sooners)

6 – USC (reminds us of post-Buster Douglas Mike Tyson)

7 – Ohio State (“new” Bucks would love rematch with USC)

8 – Missouri (still has puncher’s chance of knocking you out)

9 – Penn State (non-Big Ten foes don’t fear Nittany Lions)

10 – Utah (insert Boise State here if criteria was home field)

 

Average Competition Conference: Who can figure out what’s going on with the ACC?  North Carolina, Wake Forest and Florida State -- the three league teams ranked last week -- all lost to conference opponents. Aren’t division races supposed to get clearer as the weeks go on? The Atlantic is nearly as wide open as it was when the season began. Along the Coastal, we’re one Georgia Tech victory over Miami away from having the top five teams in the division toting at least three losses as they chase BCS dreams.

 

Heisman for the little guys: Similar to the quest for the BCS, the race for the Heisman Trophy held steady Saturday. So, instead of rehashing the same cast of candidates, how about we shine some light on someone new who’s worthy of some recognition. Weber State sophomore quarterback Cameron Higgins has thrown for 3,496 yards and 33 touchdowns, against only eight interceptions. He owns passer rating of 178.79 rating and has led the Wildcats to an undefeated record in the Big Sky Conference. How about a Heisman just for the Football Championship Subdivision? Or do we hold that back from them since they have a playoff and we’re jealous?

 

Realignment out West would look automatic: What if Utah and Boise State were in the same conference? Instead of this debate over who is more worthy of being the BCS party crasher, they (and the rest of the unappreciated teams west of the Rockies) ought to settle it on the field. If there was another round of defections and league leaping, wouldn’t a conference made up of the best in the West from the WAC and MWC create a league that would be deserving of an automatic qualifier to the BCS? Something like Utah, BYU, Nevada, UNLV, Boise State, Idaho, Fresno State, San Jose State, Hawaii and San Diego State seems to make a lot of sense. Although I’m sure the Big East and ACC wouldn’t agree. The Pac-10 wouldn’t be too happy about it either . . . but for different reasons.

 

Showdown Saturday: On the heels of a lackluster week, the upcoming slate of games, promises to be much more interesting. In fact, it is downright playoff-esque. Leading the way is the Texas Tech-Oklahoma showdown in Norman, which features two of the best dart throwers in the country. Watching Graham Harrell and Sam Bradford go throw-for-throw will be something to behold. We’ve also got the “Holy War” between Utah and Brigham Young, which also will have folks in Boise and Muncie on the edge of their seats. The weekend undercard even features middleweight bouts such as Michigan State-Penn State and Pittsburgh-Cincinnati, which will both go a long way to determining a couple BCS automatic berths. And then at the other end of the spectrum, you’ve got the rotten “Apple Cup” in which Washington and Washington State will battle for the last shred of dignity available. Don’t laugh. With a pair of teams that have combined to go 0-15 in Pac-10 play and 1-20 overall, you’ve got a rivalry game that will be as hard-fought as any contest in the country. Enjoy.

 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

The fact that Florida is SO good is THE reason you want to play them. Beat 'em, and silence all critics :)

ROLL TIDE!
Roll over the Tide is just what the Gators will do! Step aside, 'Bama, Touchdown Timmy is on his way!!
Wow Showdown Saturday and you didn't mention OSU-Mich. I don't care if Michigan is having their worst season ever, this is easily the biggest rivalry in college football and probably one of the top 3 nationally.
Please...please..please 'Bama...... PLEASE beat Florida in the SEC Championship game!  Being a Dawgs fan, seeing the Gators go again to the BCS Championship game AGAIN is just wayyyy too much.  An when Tebow tries to score a touchdown by rushing, use those big Tide defensive bodies and make him pay......
The big difference in Florida and Alabama is Alabama peaked early in the season and Florida is peaking late in the season. It's not gonna be pretty in the SEC champship game. This is one of the best teams Florida has ever had.
                       GO GATORS!!!
You will get your chance Bill. Those who talk to much are nervous!!! Ask LSU, Georgia and South Carolina. By the way what was the score of the Kentucky-Florida game? We beat them 63-5.......
Hey Bill - You're GATOR BAIT!  Alabama should be afraid to play this Gator team with the number of awesome offensive, defensive, and special team players it has.  The SEC Championship game hasn't looked like this much fun in years! :)

GO GATORS!
After rewatching some games from earlier in the season are Alabama and Goergia keeping each other in top ten. I was on the Tide wagon but I really wouldn't put money on them against any of the top 15.
Sorry BAMA man..you're going down December 6th!! GATOR BAIT!
Exactly Alabama.  When you beat them then you can talk.  Until then you are just a list of teams that will have that chance.  I personally do not think you can handle Florida's speed and even slow down Tim Tebow.
AMEN BROTHER BILL. THE GATORS HAVE NOT PLAYED BAMA YET. DON'T COUNT ALABAMA OUT OF THIS GAME. SABAN WILL FIND A WAY TO WIN.


ROLL TIDE!
not so fast my friend, speed kills.  Tide is going out for good on 12/6.
I'm a Gator fan in Bama. I'm very proud of Bama and have been cheering them on this year. Bama and Saban have turned it around. But I don't think, as much as they've improved, they'll beat the Gators. Bama's had a problem with being consistent through both halves. They either let their guard down, had too much confidence or something with LSU and either good luck or just plain skill with the rest. Don't know what happened with the Gators and Ole Miss. But when you compare the Gators and Bama, the Gators have the edge. I believe they'll beat Bama. They're consistent the whole game. Anyway, its a divided house here. Hubby, Bama. Me, GO GATORS!!!!! All the way to a championship!!!!
Florida has the atheletes, the remaining schedule, and the coach to win the Championship.  (that would be the NATIONAL, not the lil SEC thang)  Looks like once again, the best one game team in the country won't get a chance to prove it.  (you listening LS Who fans?)  USC may not even make the Rose Bowl.  Such a shame.  Weak conference year, indeed.  The worst I remember in fact.  The jury is still out on their offense.  (this is a mystery to me I admit, with their talent)  But for ONE game, (read: national Championship) USC & Florida would be a great match up.
just look at the florida gators they are the best all round team take the one loss away then who would be number one. hey bama just bring it,see you in atlanta
I'd rate USC higher right now.  Their defense is stifling, especially when the game's in doubt - and who wants to see USC play another OSU game?
Did you just use "Idaho" and "the Best in the West" in the same sentence?

If you're including Idaho as a travel partner for Boise or something, you might note that Salt Lake City is actually an hour closer to Boise (by road) than Moscow, ID is.
I've seen a lot of replays of other conferences including Pac 10 and there is a lot of flimsy arm tackling. You wouldn't get away with that in SEC. They hit.
The reason that Florida is so good is the very reason that Alabama will lose in the SEC championship game. I'm not taking anything away from the "TIDE",they have had a very good season and what can you say about Saben and Parker-Wilson. Just remember that the GATORS have an arsenal of teeth to bite anyone with.

               "GO GATORS"
Weren't all of the teams mentioned in "Realignment out West would look automatic" (save for Boise, Nevada & Idaho) in the old 16-team WAC?
I’m with you Bill.  ROLL TIDE ROLL.  If we don’t make stupid mistakes, and JP can keep the
game managed, we have a good chance against those nasty gators.  There is nothing more I
would like to see than for the Tide to silence those gators and for us to play Texas Tech for the
BCS championship!  I think we are going to see Saban play some conservative football for the
rest of the regular season to keep injuries at bay, but still play to win.  When they come out on the
field at the GA Dome on 12/6...I believe they will be ready! ROLL TIDE!!

p.s. Maybe Tebow will get a stomach flu or something. lol
If 'Bama has critics, I haven't heard them. I'd just be focused on staying the course. That GREAT game will be upon us soon enough.

Go Gators.
The TIDE will subside when the Gators march in and end 'Bama's sad reign on top.  'Bama will find themselves outclassed and overmatched.  Watch and see Bill.
Obviously we are two diehard fans for each team and the argument won't die.  But you do have to admit the Gators have crushed each team, LSU, Georgia, etc.  'Bama has not and that's why they should be worried.
Did anyone forget that Ole Miss beat the Gators at the swamp. I have yet to see an article written on "Why the Gators are getting the pass"? It doesn't make add up to me. Texas and OU lost to top 5 teams (not at home), yet Florida is getting all this praise.
many fans miss the fact that you want all your opponets highly ranked and unbeaten when you beat them...Go Gators
Florida is unstoppable as a result of the total team effort they are getting from all of their players. Last year they needed Tebow to carry the team and this year the team will be carrying Tebow to his second national championship. I would not want to be coaching a Gators opponent the rest of this year!
The Red Raiders have yet to get the respect they deserve.  Folks here in Lubbock have decided to quit hoping for respect and have decided to just take it.
The Red Raiders will embarrass your defense, that's why you don’t want to play them.

Go. Fight. Win.  TT

Bob
As a native Los Angeles born fan of all things-So Cal-athletics, I love the fact that the sports reporting media continues to be dominated by writers who've never been hit by a Taylor Mays type safety, had a jumper slapped back in their faces by a 6'6" point guard, or been beaned by a 90+ MPH fastball. By January, USC will again be at the top of this list. All that's missing is tweaking the offensive line play (Already underway). Mark it down Tamanaha, SC crushes whoever gets that assignment in the New Year, and we're hoping and praying it's Gatorish.
Where's TCU in your list of top MWC teams? You put San Diego on the list for crying out loud! Oh, and what's with the 6-4 advantage to the WAC in your realigned conference out west? The MWC has the best three teams this year (Utah, TCU, byu; yes, they would all manhandle the mighty broncos), and is easily the better conference from top to bottom. (see: Wyoming over Tennessee)

GO UTES!
Bill, I can't wait to see ya'll in the SEC championship game. You think our recent scores were embarassing just watch what we do to the number one Crimson. (if Bama can even hold it)

GO GATORS!
If another conference is created, why would anyone want Idaho in it? Since leaving the Sunbelt conference in 2005 their record in the WAC is 9-37 (6-25 within the WAC) how would this help the "new" conference at all, and the same goes to the equally horrid San Diego State... why not just drop San Diego State and Wyoming back into the WAC and send Boise State and Nevada or Louisiana Tech into the MWC?
I cannot understand anyone putting OU ahead of Texas at this point in the season.  Texas beat OU by 10 points on a neutral field and barely lost to a red-hot Texas Tech in Lubbock after playing 3 quarters of bad football and with several people banged up.  Why on earth would you have OU ahead of Texas before Tech and OU even play?  Even if OU wins...they beat Tech at home not in Lubbock and I still think you have to give the nod to Texas since they won the head to head matchup.  Not to mention, do you really think this Sooners defense is better than Texas'?  Oh yeah, Texas already proved it isn't when they played OU and BEAT them by rattling Sam Bradford in the 2nd half.  At least the coaches had the brains this week to rectify putting OU in front of Texas in the polls.
This is ridiculous.  I am okay with Florida at the top, but USC should be second on this list at least, not 6th.  Tamanaha...you are now Tamaha hahahahaha...nice joke sir.
BE CAREFUL BIG GUY, ROLLTIDE IS RIGHT, BUT I AM STUCK HERE IN GATOR COUNTRY AND I SURE HOPE THE TIDE CAN TAKE EM DOWN A NOTCH THEY ARE SCARY GOOD RECENTLY
Florida is patiently waiting for you.  Keep Talking!! At least you do that well!!

GO GATORS !!!!!
The realignment seems to make sense. Every team has a travel partner like the Pac 10 and you have to have a couple of bottom feeder type teams in any conference to give it balance.  Plus, it also has to make sense for the remaining teams.
I've said all season that the only team that scares me to have the Tide play was the Gators...WIN LOSE or DRAW we are going to be witness to ONE HELLUVA GAME!!!!
GL to both sides :)
Oregon had 694 yards on the 13th ranked defense in the country in their house... and if you think they're not scarier than Missouri at this point you just ain't watching... with Jeremy Masoli passing for 250+ two games in a row, THIS is the best offense in the country. The Holiday Bowl with the Ducks against Texas Tech should be the most entertaining game of the bowl season.
USC is one of the best defenses in history, some say five first rounders at the very least... and they remind you of Tyson post Douglas? Cute, which of course is WAY more important than being accurate, but factually ridiculous. East Coast bias; BS.
I've been an Alabama fan for over 50yrs. It's always better to go in a game being the underdog, that way, the team remains focused, poised and ready to play the game. Remember the '92 championship game, all you heard was Miami, Miami, Miami. Looked what happened!
ROLL TIDE ROLL!!!
hey tide gang...you need to use it in the wash room before the week is out...but, either way, the gators will clean your clocks..and,,,SEC rules
seeya'll soon...go gators..mac
I'm happy that an SEC team will be going to the BCS Championship again this year. I'm glad that it is Florida, but I would be happy if it was any other SEC team also. Airborne All The Way! Go Gators!
Gators will repeat in football just as they did in BBall.  Its titletown in Gainesville till further notice.  UGA LSU UT FSU all the usual suspects will simply have to take the beat down,  The USC/Texas sham will have to do what Oklahoma did take the back seat.  Pac ten is one team wonder.  Big 12 plays no defense.  Gators are most complete team in run away best conference in college football.  Go Gators let the posers beware. thats 3 football and 2 basketball in 12 yrs ans 2 & 2 in 3 yrs.  Read em and weep...


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):